Better than AFI’s Heroes and Villains: Villain #29

The character:Arnold Friend
The actor:Treat Williams
The movie:Smooth Talk (1985)

Today I’m not enough of a contrarian to tell you that Someone’s Watching Me! is better than Halloween, but I’ll tell you that I am much, much more interested in the former than the latter. Halloween might be more inventive, and its most stunning shots are more potent than those of Someone’s Watching Me…except for one. It’s the shot where we see a man in black running through Leigh’s apartment while she’s on the phone, facing away from the room he’s careening through. That shot is about as frightening as they come, working on a very simple principle underlining all horror or thriller or suspense pictures: “that,” whatever “that” is, shouldn’t be there. It’s a lot easier to do this in the dark, and to Carpenter’s credit, it’s broad daylight when we see the creep rushing out of Leigh’s place.

Joyce Chopra’s Small Talk is masterful work, but if you want to apply the difficulty standards that I’m happily applying to Someone’s Watching Me, then it’s more than that. It’s running the horror movie on whatever difficulty has all the college football people in my feed consistently throwing picks in the red zone. The monster appears in the evening, awkwardly pointing and gesticulating and trying to send Connie looks through his sunglasses. Then he appears again on a Sunday in the full sun of a western afternoon. Protected by the twin powers of daylight and the Lord’s Day, there should be no safer moment for a young woman to live in. The monster is outside, but he seems basically sated; even an anaconda is docile as long as it’s got a fawn in its belly. She can go in and out as she pleases to observe. She can lock the door when she gets tired of him, and then it all disappears until her mom gets home and then they can be mad at each other again and so on and so forth until one of them drops dead.

Michael Myers’ defining quality as a horror icon is his inevitability. He never stops. He always walks away. He’s forever in the rearview mirror. Pinch yourself to see if you’re really seeing him; it’s too dark to make out anything more than the mask or the blade. Arnold Friend is every bit as relentless as Michael Myers, but he speaks, and you can see him from a mile away. He drives a gold car inscribed with automotive tramp stamps. He talks, and he keeps talking, and he always has an answer. In fifteen minutes of screen time, which is fifteen minutes of real time, Arnold Friend takes Connie from casual flirtation to shivering behind the stairs. No single line of dialogue on its own makes him frightening. No single pose, not even the one where he pushes his nose into the screen door, makes him frightening. It is the suite of actions taken together which make him a nightmare figure by day.

Arnold Friend won’t hear no. He won’t go away. He has backup, even if he screams at his backup to stop suggesting things like “I can cut the phone lines for you.” He knows more than he ought to know, even if some of what he’s spouting is just Sherlockian inference. If he were a competitive runner or a coal miner, then he’d earn plaudits for an iron will. But he’s a guy, and because he’s a guy impressing himself on a girl, a full-grown man who’s chosen a teenager to devour, that iron will is not the stuff of lore but the experience that every woman in America recognizes.

One thought on “Better than AFI’s Heroes and Villains: Villain #29”

Leave a Reply