Better than AFI’s Heroes and Villains: Hero #29

The character:Brian Wilson
The actor:Paul Dano
The movie:Love & Mercy (2014)

My favorite scene in The Passion of the Christ is the one where Jesus invents the table. You know the one.

A lot of the Paul Dano scenes in Love & Mercy are like Jesus inventing the table, even more than the average music biopic is about building tables. The sequence where he starts banging out “God Only Knows” at the piano while his perpetually displeased father throws mud at it is a table-builder. Some of the scenes in the recording studio where people say things like, “Gee, Brian, are you sure you want us to play the alto doohickey during what’s ostensibly a pop song?” are table-builders. I cringe a little at those moments just as much as I’ve cringed at the like moments from James Mangold’s tastefully awful music biopics. What makes Love & Mercy special, when it comes to those important scenes where Pet Sounds is born, is its focus on the cadenced joy of making. Sure, making art is about the agony and the ecstasy, like we learn from Michelangelo, but it’s not really about the agony at all. It’s about Brian on his back in the recording studio, surrounded with what he’s expelled from his mind and gotten some other people to fabricate for him. For days, weeks, he has gone into this studio and put his whole energy into the making of Pet Sounds. Now he gets to hear it back, as real as it was in his head and now real for everyone else who doesn’t have to live in there with him.

I come to you today as a guy on the interwebs. I blog as a hobby because I like to think about movies and store my thoughts somewhere. I am about as close to Brian Wilson as I am to Toni Morrison, and I don’t say any of this to self-aggrandize or act like I’m more than a guy on WordPress. Still, what I found amazing about Love & Mercy was the cadenced joy, a feeling of continuing productivity, the attainment that happens over and over again until you think you’ll always feel it. I’ve felt it twice in my life. The first time, I was working on the first project that I took seriously on this blog, back when I’d seen like 1,500 movies and thought I should try to put together a top 100 American movies list. The second time was years later, when I was working through the first, and so far only, half of what will unquestionably be the great American novel. I haven’t known it since, and I don’t expect it to come back. It doesn’t just come back.

I learned my lesson after the original “Better than AFI” list. I thought it was going to make a new chapter in my life as a blogger, and it turned out that what had happened was all mayfly. I had been watching good movies and writing about them and watching good movies and writing about them, and I was discovering so much and trying to synthesize it as fast as I could. It was intoxicating, and it was over within a month. It was the cadence that brought the joy. Much the same thing happened while I was writing the fiction piece; for a month or two, I averaged over 1,000 words a day, and that was a thrill of its own. They were not blissful, but they were happy. I saw those moments from my own life in Brian Wilson conducting dogs or singing “Caroline, No” or directing from the booth. Almost nothing feels as good.

It’s no wonder that the John Cusack version of Wilson, who I’m not including here, seems so shriveled. Losing battles to Eugene Landy or Mike Love or his evil father or whoever else aren’t the things that have shriveled him. The cadenced joy is gone. Unable to access that joy, there’s strikingly little there for someone who has reached fantastic heights and now only has the view.

One thought on “Better than AFI’s Heroes and Villains: Hero #29”

Leave a Reply